Beyond State-Community Polarisations and Bogus "Joint"ness: Crafting Institutional Solutions for Resource Management

Lele, Sharachchandra (2004) Beyond State-Community Polarisations and Bogus "Joint"ness: Crafting Institutional Solutions for Resource Management. In: Globalisation, Poverty and Conflict: a critical development reader. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Netherlands , 283-303.. ISBN 9781402028571

[img] Text
GPC_lele_pg_283-303_2004.pdf - Published Version
Restricted to Registered users only

Download (8MB)

Abstract

Decentralised collective action is no longer on trial in the current academic debate on natural resources management.2What still needs to be worked out are the conditions for its success and its optimal nesting in or relationship with other institutions.A vast body of research has addressed the question of under what (external) conditions decentralised collective action will succeed (for a recent review, see Agarwal 200 1, specificallyin the context of forests, see Ostrom 1998). But there seems much less debate, let alone agreement, on the question of relationships between local-level collective action institutions and other institutions at different levels. From the perspective of those interested in proving that community-level institutions of resource management can and do work, often the only role the state can (and should) play is "non interference" or at most "legitimisation"? Ifthe need for "nested enterprises" has been recognised, it is only in the case of common-pool resources that are part of a larger system (Ostrom 1990:90). Even here, the precise meaning and form of "nestedness" are yet to be elaborated. 4The focus has remained on the conditions of success for local-level collective actionin which the state implicitly has a minimal role. Others have recognised that the neat separation of state, community and private property regimes is only a theoretical one, and that in fact resource rights or tenure regimes are better characterised as variations in the manner in which different strands

Item Type: Book Section
Additional Information: Copyright of this article belongs to Kluwer Academic Publishers
Subjects: C Publications by ATREEians > H Book Chapters
Divisions: Publications by ATREEians > Book Chapters
Depositing User: Users 103 not found.
Date Deposited: 07 Dec 2016 05:42
Last Modified: 24 Apr 2019 10:30
URI: http://eprints.atree.org/id/eprint/349

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item